New York City
2 - 1
Toronto
0-2
L
0-0
D
3-1
W
1-0
L
2-0
L
0-1
L
1-4
L
1-1
D
2-0
L
0-2
L
Half time: 1 - 1
Elapsed: FT
Kick off: 23:30 UTC
Date: Sat 16-Mar-24
Wheater: clear sky
 |  |  | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York City | 6 | 4 | 1 | 2 |
| Toronto | 4 | 5 | 0 | 1 |
New York City 4-3-3Toronto 3-4-2-1F. Matthew49T. Martins Bueno13B. Risa5M. Ilenčič35K. Alexander Parks55H. Wolf
17S. Rodríguez Molina10J. Sands6K. O'Toole22M. Bakrar9J. Fernández11L. Gavran90K. Long5S. Rosted17S. O'Neill27D. Flores20M. Longstaff8A. Coello Camarero14L. Insigne24F. Bernardeschi10P. Owusu99J. Marshall-Rutty7| Assist: Alonso Coello Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty 0-1 | 7' | | ||
| Kevin Long | 23' | | ||
| 24' | 1-1 Santiago Rodríguez | ||
| Federico Bernardeschi | 28' | | ||
| 42' | Birk Risa | ||
| out: Matthew Longstaff Kobe Franklin | 46' |  | ||
| out: Prince Osei Owusu Kosi Thompson | 57' | | ||
| 63' | Keaton Parks | ||
| 64' | 2-1 Kevin O'Toole Assist: Julián Fernández | ||
| 67' | ||||
| 68' | Keaton Parks | ||
| 70' | Andrés Perea out: Julián Fernández | ||
| Shane O'Neill | 71' | | ||
| out: Sigurd Rosted Tyrese Spicer | 75' | | ||
| out: Alonso Coello Ayo Akinola | 75' | | ||
| 83' | Tayvon Gray out: Hannes Wolf | ||
| out: Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty Deandre Kerr | 90+3' | | ||
| 90+5' | James Sands | ||
| Lorenzo Insigne | 90+7' | | ||
| Kosi Thompson | 90+7' | | ||
| 90' | Justin Haak out: Monsef Bakrar | ||
| 90+3' | Justin Haak | ||
Lineups
New York City
 | 49F. Matthew Goalkeeper |
 | 13T. Martins Bueno Dedender |
 | 5B. Risa42' Dedender |
 | 35M. Ilenčič Dedender |
 | 55K. Alexander Parks63'67'68' Midfielder |
 | 17H. Wolf83' Forward |
 | 10S. Rodríguez Molina24' Midfielder |
 | 6J. Sands90'+5 Midfielder |
 | 22K. O'Toole64' Dedender |
 | 9M. Bakrar90' Forward |
 | 11J. Fernández70' Forward |
Toronto
 | 90L. Gavran Goalkeeper |
 | 5K. Long23' Dedender |
 | 17S. Rosted75' Dedender |
 | 27S. O'Neill71' Dedender |
 | 20D. Flores Midfielder |
 | 8M. Longstaff46' Forward |
 | 14A. Coello Camarero75' Midfielder |
 | 24L. Insigne90'+7 Forward |
 | 10F. Bernardeschi28' Midfielder |
 | 99P. Owusu57' Forward |
 | 7J. Marshall-Rutty7'90'+3 Midfielder |
Substitutes
New York City
 | 80J. Haak90'90'+3 Midfielder |
 | 16A. Martínez Batista Forward |
 | 1L. Barraza Goalkeeper |
 | 8A. Perea Castañeda70' Midfielder |
 | 12S. Tanasijević Dedender |
 | 21A. Jasson Midfielder |
 | 24T. Gray83' Dedender |
 | 26A. Ojeda Forward |
 | 7J. Mijatović Forward |
Toronto
 | 6A. Mabika Dedender |
 | 47K. Thompson57'90'+7 Midfielder |
 | 18G. Ranjitsingh Goalkeeper |
 | 19K. Franklin46' Dedender |
 | 9A. Akinola75' Forward |
 | 29D. Kerr90'+3 Forward |
 | 77J. Perruzza Forward |
 | 16T. Spicer75' Forward |
 | 12C. Mailula Forward |
Sidelined / Injured
New York City
| P | Player | Reason | Apps | G | A |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| M | M. Moralez | ACL Knee Injury | 21 | 1 | 5 |
| D | R. Hope-Gund | Abdominal Strain |
Toronto
| P | Player | Reason | Apps | G | A |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| D | N. Gomis | Broken Wrist | 24 | ||
| D | R. Laryea | Thigh Injury | 12 | 1 | 2 |
| A | D. Kerr | Calf Injury | 26 | 3 | 2 |
| A | J. Perruzza | Groin Injury | |||
| M | B. Servania | ACL Knee Injury | 3 |