New York City
2 - 0
Orlando City
1-0
W
2-0
L
1-1
D
2-0
W
0-0
D
0-0
L
0-1
W
1-0
W
0-2
W
3-2
W
Half time: 1 - 0
Elapsed: FT
Kick off: 23:30 UTC
Date: Wed 20-Sep-23
Wheater: clear sky
 |  |  | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York City | 6 | 1 | 0 | 2 |
| Orlando City | 5 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
New York City 4-3-3Orlando City 4-2-3-1F. Matthew49T. Gray24T. Martins Bueno13B. Risa5K. O'Toole22A. Perea Castañeda
15J. Sands6A. Jasson21S. Rodríguez Molina10R. Ledezma20M. Bakrar9P. Gallese Quiróz1D. Þórhallsson23R. Schlegel15R. Jansson6R. Cardoso dos Santos3C. Araújo Vilches5W. Cartagena Mendoza16F. Torres Pérez17M. Pereyra Antonini10I. Angulo Cortés77R. Enrique Paz7| 36' | ||||
| 37' | 1-0 Monsef Bakrar | ||
 | 37' | Santiago Rodríguez | ||
| 41' | Richard Ledezma | ||
| Mauricio Pereyra | 45+1' | | ||
| Wilder Cartagena | 54' | | ||
| out: Wilder Cartagena Martín Ojeda | 59' |  | ||
| out: Ramiro Enrique Duncan McGuire | 59' | | ||
| 59' | Talles Magno out: Richard Ledezma | ||
| out: Rafael Santos Luca Petrasso | 59' | | ||
| 68' | 2-0 Talles Magno Assist: Andres Jasson | ||
| out: Iván Angulo Gastón González | 80' | | ||
| out: Mauricio Pereyra Michael Halliday | 80' | | ||
| 90+4' | Julián Fernández out: Santiago Rodríguez | ||
| 90+2' | Justin Haak out: Andrés Perea | ||
| 90+4' | Mitja Ilenič out: Andres Jasson | ||
| 90+2' | Brian Cufré out: Monsef Bakrar | ||
Lineups
New York City
 | 49F. Matthew Goalkeeper |
 | 24T. Gray Dedender |
 | 13T. Martins Bueno Dedender |
 | 5B. Risa Dedender |
 | 22K. O'Toole Dedender |
 | 15A. Perea Castañeda90'+2 Midfielder |
 | 6J. Sands Midfielder |
 | 21A. Jasson90'+4 Forward |
 | 10S. Rodríguez Molina36'37'90'+4 Forward |
 | 20R. Ledezma41'59' Midfielder |
 | 9M. Bakrar37'90'+2 Forward |
Orlando City
 | 1P. Gallese Quiróz Goalkeeper |
 | 23D. Þórhallsson Dedender |
 | 15R. Schlegel Dedender |
 | 6R. Jansson Dedender |
 | 3R. Cardoso dos Santos59' Dedender |
 | 5C. Araújo Vilches Midfielder |
 | 16W. Cartagena Mendoza54'59' Midfielder |
 | 17F. Torres Pérez Midfielder |
 | 10M. Pereyra Antonini45'+180' Midfielder |
 | 77I. Angulo Cortés80' Midfielder |
 | 7R. Enrique Paz59' Forward |
Substitutes
New York City
 | 1L. Barraza Goalkeeper |
 | 34S. Turnbull Dedender |
 | 33N. Benalcazar Dedender |
 | 3B. Cufré90'+2 Dedender |
 | 35M. Ilenčič90'+4 Dedender |
| 11J. Fernández90'+4 Forward |
 | 80J. Haak90'+2 Midfielder |
 | 16A. Martínez Batista Forward |
 | 43T. Bacelar Martins59'68' Forward |
Orlando City
 | 31M. Stajduhar Goalkeeper |
 | 20L. Petrasso59' Midfielder |
 | 26M. Halliday80' Dedender |
 | 24K. Smith Dedender |
 | 11M. Ojeda59' Midfielder |
 | 8F. Martins Campanholi Midfielder |
 | 21O. de Almeida Júnior Midfielder |
 | 22G. González80' Forward |
 | 13D. McGuire59' Forward |